John Yandell: The Myth of the Pitch

“Serving is just like pitching a baseball.” Probably everyone who ever took a serving lesson has heard this claim. It’s is one of the most common myths in teaching. Unfortunately, it’s not an accurate description. It’s of minimal value in learning to serve and can even be counterproductive. This is especially true if the student has actually played baseball and can throw or pitch well. Is this the model for the serve? How much does the serve really have in common with the pitching motion in baseball? Actually the baseball pitching analogy is part of a larger category of misleading analogy myths. Hitting a one-handed backhand is “just like” drawing a sword out of scabbard. Hitting a forehand volley is “just like” throwing a punch. Then there’s a teaching pro, and a regular correspondent who insists that serving isn’t really like throwing a ball at all. Really, it’s just like throwing a javelin! There are two related problems with these analogies. First, rather than simplifying our explanations of the strokes, they actually make them more complex. What a tennis serve most resembles isn’t a baseball pitch, a javelin throw, or any other motion from any other sport. The motion a…